Saturday, February 18, 2017

Augmented Seventh Heaven and Other Deceits in "The Good Place"

The ident music for NBC’s afterlife comedy "The Good Place" uses a cliché harmonic signifier of fantasy: a progression between two major triads a major third apart, in which the triad rooted on the “higher” note of the major third serves as tonic. (An earlier blog post also spent some time with music that uses this progression.) Here’s a typical way that this harmonic progression is realized, in The Good Place’s key of A major:


Music theorist Richard Cohn has made the case that progressions like this earn their otherworldly signification because one cannot understand both the horizontal voice-leading semitones as diatonic minor seconds—a common default—and the vertical harmonic intervals as diatonic consonances. In the notation above, the triads are spelled diatonically, but the alto’s voice leading (C#-C-C#) is not, as highlighted with the dashed lines. This line could be spelled diatonically as C#-B#-C#, which would make the melodic intervals diatonic, but this would prevent the F-major triad from being spelled diatonically, as shown below; again, the dashed lines indicate non-diatonic intervals. To quote the Ninth Doctor Who: “You push one problem under the carpet and another one pops out on the other side.” This progression is simply too chromatic to hide all of it—both its chords and its lines—under diatonic carpets.


This sense that understanding a harmonic interval as commonplace keeps one from understanding a melodic interval as commonplace, or vice versa, jibes nicely with the deceits in The Good Place. However, the deceits of the first season’s last episode took the very notion of deception to another level. Likewise, The Good Place’s ident music is not your typical diatonic-interval-frustrating chromatic-mediant progression, for two reasons.

First of all, at least in nineteenth-century art music and mainstream screen music, many, and perhaps most, chromatic-mediant progressions are purely diatonic in both their vertical and horizontal intervals in their outer voices. For example, in the realizations above, the outer voices only use As, Es, and Fs, which form perfect fifths, octaves, major thirds, and minor seconds. (Same with the “Panem National Anthem” linked to above, and countless others.) Therefore, the deceit usually involves only one or more inside voices, like the alto voice above. Unlike the more conspicuous outer voices, inner voices more easily shutter the irreconcilability between horizontal and vertical away from prying ears. In other words, in the realization above, a little of the progression may not fit under a diatonic carpet, but the exposure is slight, pushed toward a dimly lit corner of the room.

A permutation of the upper voices that puts the C#-C-C# in the top voice, as shown below, would call more attention to this exposure. Perhaps because of this attention, this melodic line is not used as often for this harmonic progression.


Second of all, while it is reasonable to assume a default of a minor-second interpretation for a semitone, it does not take much to override this default. Take a purely ascending or purely descending motion through a chromatic scale, like the one below. Most composers and listeners would notate and understand nearly half of its intervals—around 42%, to be more exact—as augmented unisons (the 5 out of 12 slurs below the line) instead of minor seconds (the 7 out of 12 slurs above the line). 


But what if the voice leading used the same intervals as those of the harmonies? This would avoid any double standard of diatonic reckoning. This is exactly what we get with the ident music for The Good Place, as shown below. Not only are the outer voices involved in the diatonic irreconcilability, but the top line—played by the oboe—leaps directly from C#5 to the white note four semitones higher, while the bass leaps from A down to F (best spelled as such since the A remains a common tone). Either this new note is an E#5 and the melody uses a diatonic major third but the harmony contains an augmented seventh...


...or the new note is a F5 and the harmony is diatonic but the melody spans a diminished fourth.


I remember hearing this music for the first time and disbelieving that it was an F-major triad, so strong was my sense that the oboe was playing an E# in a consonant major triad. Here was a rare realization of this progression indeed, one that uses voice leading to cover as much “surface area” on a line of perfect fifths as the harmonic progression allows: in the bass, the flattest note in the A major harmony (A) moves down a major third—which is the one directed consonance that transports a note the farthest in a flatward direction—and, in the treble, the sharpest note in the A-major harmony (C#) moves up a major third—which is the one directed consonance that transports a note the farthest in a sharpward direction. The result is music that fits even less well under diatonic carpets than standard realizations of the progression. It’s no wonder certain deceits were exposed at the end of Season One.

What is even more remarkable is how this music compares to, and contrasts with, the music that plays right as the biggest deceit of all is revealed toward the end of the final episode: although it uses a transposition (by major third!) of the same down-by-major-third progression, both its harmony (consonant triads) and voice leading (all moving voices move down by major third) are entirely diatonic, as shown below. No deceits here (apparently).


Wednesday, January 25, 2017

Haydn, Sonata Form, and Schenker

A year ago, I proposed a perspective that correlated two oddities. The first oddity is a voice-leading and formal irreconcilability that arises when applying Schenker's theory to sonata-form recapitulations, particularly secondary themes. The second oddity is a set of interesting alterations that Mozart made in the lead-up to the recapitulation of his secondary theme in the first movement of his Piano Sonata in C Major, K. 279. The second oddity appears to mitigate the first oddity, because scale degree 3, which is the primary treble tone for the entire movement, receives more emphasis at the beginning of the subordinate theme in the recapitulation than it did in the beginning of the subordinate theme in the exposition. This makes the recap's subordinate theme a clearer vehicle for the movement's ultimate tonal closure: transporting scale degree 3 down by step to the final scale degree 1.

Something similar happens in the last movement of Joseph Haydn's last (and, according to some, his greatest) piano sonata in E-flat major. Here is the beginning of the movement, which presents the primary theme. In the third issue of his self-authored periodical Der Tonwille, Schenker designates scale degree 5 (B flat) as the primary treble tone for the movement. I choose scale degree 3 (G) instead.


In general, Haydn is well known for making witty and sometimes surreptitious alterations to the recapitulations of his secondary themes, rather than merely producing the secondary theme of the recapitulation by "copying, pasting, and transposing" the exposition's subordinate theme into the tonic key. The examples below compare two moments in the subordinate theme ("S-theme") of the exposition to their corresponding moments in the recapitulation. In both of these moments, an F (scale degree 2 in the main key, and scale degree 5 in the subordinate key) is replaced by G (scale degree 3 in the main key) instead of a B flat, which is the note that a simple "copy-paste" transposition would have delivered. Both of these moments are initiating moments, and the first in particular, with its five repeated eighth notes, harkens back to the primary theme's initiation. They encourage a reinterpretation of the recap's secondary theme's treble line as tracing an overall 3-2-1 path instead of an overall 5-4-3-2-1 path as it more likely did in the exposition. Like my interpretation of K. 279/i, this interpretation of Haydn XVI:52/iii better connects the primary treble tone of the primary theme in the exposition and recapitulation to the secondary theme's initiating tone in the recapitulation.




Thursday, December 1, 2016

Octaves Above Milstein's Prokofiev is...Sort of the Same Prokofiev

It is not too far-fetched, or at least not unprecedented, to identify an even division of time too slow to be heard as a pitch with a label that customarily is assigned to a pitch. For example, the sound waves emanating from a black hole in the Perseus Cluster have been identified as a B flat, although they are too low to be heard: indeed, the crests of the waves are millions of years apart. But to label this frequency with a pitch is simple enough. Multiplying or dividing a frequency by 2n moves it up or down, respectively, by n octaves. This transfer by one or more octaves both preserves its letter name and potentially puts it within the range of human hearing where we typically categorize frequencies with letters. For example, 440 Hz is an A, and so is 880 Hz, 1760 Hz, 220 Hz, 110 Hz, and the rate at which the moon goes around the earth (the sidereal month of 27.321661 days). Well, actually the sidereal month is a rather high A (30 octaves lower than ~459 Hz); in fact, it is closer to the black hole's B flat (of which one is ~466 Hz).

With this in mind, consider the opening of Prokofiev's Second Violin Concerto in G minor, which was premiered in Madrid on this day 81 years ago. It begins with a G, B-flat, D, E-flat, C sharp, and another D played by the soloist, and then this rising motive repeats in its entirety. The frequency at which the rising motive appears can also be labeled as a pitch. Prokofiev indicated a tempo of quarter = 108, which makes the motive's frequency a slightly low F sharp. While some commercially recorded performers roughly take that tempo, many others tend to go slower: around an F or even around an E for the rising motive. But Nathan Milstein, in a live recording from 51 years ago, not only plays it faster than what Prokofiev requests (and with relatively little rubato), but also plays the rising motive "at a G," several octaves below the open-string G he plays to begin the concerto, a G that matches the opening tonal center of the concerto.

Prokofiev follows this rising motive and its repetition with a descending motive (D-C-Bb) and its embellished repetitions that extend the motive lower and longer by one suffixed note with each repetition. However, thanks to durational reductions of interior notes, each descending motive still takes up the same amount of time; therefore, the frequency of the descending motive can still be labeled by a single pitch letter. Milstein's tempo for this portion puts the descending motive's frequency at around a B. Although the descending motives neither contain a B nor are in B, the immediately following orchestral statement of the ascending and descending motives is transposed to start on, and position the tonal center on, B.

The movie below demonstrates these pitch-tempo relationships.


Thanks to Debbie Rifkin for encouraging me to think about this concerto.

Friday, November 4, 2016

Some Unused Counterpoint in Brahms's First Symphony

Brahms's First Symphony in C Minor premiered 140 years ago today. Its first movement finds ingenious ways to combine its motives and themes together in counterpoint. (Julian Horton's video for the Society for Music Analysis provides an insightful introduction to these motives, themes, and combinations.)

In the exposition, Brahms shows how an inverted form of the main theme meshes well with the closing theme. In the instance below, the inverted main theme is in the bass, while the closing theme is in the treble. Eight measures later, he swaps their registral positions.




In the development, Brahms shows how the closing theme can be well combined with itself in canon at the octave a half-measure later. In the instance below, the dux (leading voice) is in the treble, while the comes (the imitating voice) is in the bass. Eight measures later, he swaps their registral positions.



What Brahms never does in the symphony is combine these two instances of two-part counterpoint into an instance of three-part counterpoint, which works quite well in forming seven complete triads while maintaining independence among all three voices. One possible version, transposed to the key of the symphony, is below.

Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Carter Burwell's Musical Accuracy in The Chamber

Perhaps the most appreciated part of The Chamber, a film adaptation of the John Grisham novel by the same name that was widely released in theaters exactly twenty years ago today, was the musical score by Carter Burwell. One of the parts of Burwell's score that I especially appreciate is the music that accompanies the end of an impassioned closing argument (around 1:09:00) that young lawyer Adam Hall (Chris O'Donnell) is making in court on behalf of his client and grandfather Sam Cayhall (Gene Hackman), who is scheduled to be executed for a racially motivated murder.

The musical content is quite straightforward: it is in E-flat major, the harmonies alternate back and forth between an E-flat major triad and a G-minor triad, the melody rises do-re-mi three times, and the texture thickens and dynamics rise gradually over the course of the cue. The tonal-harmonic aspects involve what I have called a "loss gesture" and have written about here and here and demonstrated here.

But that's not what I especially appreciate. The "loss gesture" works well when a listener well perceives the transition from one triad to another. The soundtrack is dominated by Chris O'Donnell's dialogue. What I admire is how Burwell's harmonic changes find holes in the dialogue. He finds not only big holes in between sentences, of course, but also two smaller holes within sentences: the 0.8-second hole between "It's a tragedy that" and "has destroyed three lives already," and the even smaller 0.4-second hole between "He was" and "raised by his family and this state to become the man that he became."

Below is a transcription of the music and the dialogue that notates time exactly proportional to space. (Sts. = strings, Brs. = brass, +W.W. = woodwinds are added.) The holes are indicated with enclosures whose color matches the description above.


Sunday, September 4, 2016

Folding Phish's Tweezer

At Dick’s Sporting Goods Park in Commerce City, CO, the rock group Phish is playing their last show of their 2016 summer tour as I post this. As phish.net says, "If there is a single Phish song that can be said to evolve with and exemplify Phish’s sound and artistry over the decades, it’s 'Tweezer.'" Below is a simplification of the famous opening lick, in "Tweezer Reprise"'s key of D. Here is a recording.

I've spent some time on this blog analogizing pitch and time. Here's one way that they are related:

The gamut of pitch register lays out linearly, from low to high, but it also circles back on itself via the concept of the octave: "do-re-mi-fa-so-la-ti...do." Even though the second "do" is higher than the first, we still call them both "do." In fact, of all of these notes within the octave, this "do" is special: it is the tonic, the note toward which all of the others are oriented.

The expanse of chronological time lays out linearly, from earlier to later, but it also circles back on itself via the concept of the measure: "1-2-3-4...1." Even though the second "1" is later than the first, we still call them both "1." In fact, of all of these beats within the measure, this "1" is special: it is the downbeat, the beat toward which all of the others are oriented.

Now these five notes from "Tweezer"' have a rare property, and they have this property not only because of how far apart they are from one another in pitch and in time, but also because of what the tonic and the downbeat are.

This video describes this property.


This was the "one from rock music" I was referring to a year ago here. The first four notes of Gershwin's "I Got Rhythm" have the same property, but I hope I explained it better this time around. I can think of another song released in 2015 with a similar lick and the same tonal and metric orientation.

Sunday, August 14, 2016

In Die Walküre, Space Becomes Time

Wagner's complete tetralogy Der Ring des Nibelungen was first presented 140 years ago yesterday. The one part of this music that has probably embedded itself into Western cultural consciousness the most is the beginning of the third act of the second opera Die Walküre, the so-called "Ride of the Valkyries." The image below provides a notation of the first presentation of the melody. While the severe distortion of the notation makes it harder to read, it makes the distance that a measure of time and a semitone of pitch takes up on the image more equal to one another. All of the melody's local maxima (B3-D4-F4#-A4-C#5) divide this 14-semitone span into a 3+4+3+4 organization. The dominant-(5)-to-tonic(1) moments of the melody divide this 14-measure span into a 3+4+3+4 organization.


P.S. My post title cheekily refers to the fact that, in Wagner's last opera Parsifal, Gurnemanz tells Parsifal that that in this realm time becomes space ("Zum Raum wird hier die Zeit").

Sunday, July 31, 2016

Film Music Style as Guide for Late Beethoven

There is something entertaining, if not a little anachronistically naughty, about hearing a kind of more recent music in the music of someone like Beethoven (like hearing this in Beethoven's 7th symphony, or hearing this in Beethoven's 8th piano sonata). But here's an instance where it can be quite helpful. (There's a relevant cognition experiment of mine here that I invite you to try, but, if you decide to take part, do so before reading on.)

A year ago on this blog, I shared this trend about recent popular film music: "When two major triads whose roots are four semitones apart are adjacent, the triad with the root four semitones above is significantly more likely to be the tonal superior." This happens particularly when the two chords have been isolated from other tonal obligations and, without such obligations to gain tonal meaning, instead look toward one another.

In measure 13 of the first movement of Beethoven's op. 109 piano sonata, the notes of a D-sharp-major triad fill up most of the register of the piano and our attention with its sonorous and solid proportions, blocking from view much of what had occurred before. Then its firm surface suddenly shimmers and transforms into a B-major triad. To some film-music ears, this is a departure from stability and security: since B is four semitones lower than D-sharp, B is demoted in this two-character drama within a drama. I indicate this visually with a red arrow that fades into purple.
In sonata form -- a drama which this drama is within -- the recapitulation is both a return to and a reworking of the material from the exposition. In the first movement of Beethoven's op. 109, measure 62 in the recapitulation corresponds to measure 13 in the exposition. This time, it is a C-major triad that floods our senses much the same way that the D-sharp-minor triad did before. But its corresponding transformation is to an E-major triad, whose root is four semitones higher. The same harmonic conversion is now a homecoming, which I show with an arrow that changes from purple to red.
To be sure, this harmonic scheme is rather standard: the sonata is in E, and B is accustomed to its subservient role when E is the tonal sovereign. But local harmonies, together with a future music's chromatic tendencies, enrich this relationship and even offer a guide, however anachronistic, to the work's overall tonal plot.

Monday, June 27, 2016

Muse's Voice Leading at the Olympics

The 2016 Olympics are around the corner. The official song of the 2012 Olympics— “Survival,” by the British alternative rock band Muse—premiered on the radio on this day four years ago.

The lyrics of the opening are “Race, life’s a – race, That I’m gonna – win, yes I’m gonna – win, And I’ll light the – fuse, and I’ll never – lose…” The music accompanying these lyrics uses the triadic progression of BbM – Bb+ – Ebm – CbM – GbM, where M is major, m is minor, and + is augmented. The progression can also be considered in terms of smooth voice leading. First, one by one, each of the three voices in the BbM triad—on Bb, D, or F—moves up by a semitone, achieving the CbM triad. After this, two of the three voices in the CbM triad slip back down to make the GbM triad. Only the voice that started on the F and moved up to Gb never retreats, at least not until the progression starts over. Therefore, one can say that only this voice “wins,” as animated below, with the gold-colored figure as the winning voice.



What makes this more fitting is that, at least at the beginning of the song, Muse’s lead singer, Matt Bellamy, is intoning his first-person account of victory using precisely the notes of the “winning” voice. Now this, literally, is…VOICE…LEADING.

Saturday, May 28, 2016

Researching Some Music in Ligeti's Musica ricercata

The composer György Ligeti was born 93 years ago today. Here is a relationship between pitches and meters in some music from Ligeti's Musica ricerata that requires a little investment upfront.

1. A measure like 2/4 can be represented by the ordered series of positive integers 2-1, where 2 is the strong beat and 1 is the weak beat. Likewise, a measure of 3/4 can be represented as 2-1-1. A measure of 4/4, instead of being represented by 2-1-1-1, is often thought to have a metrical accent halfway through that is not as strong as the downbeat, but stronger than the weak beats: this could be represented as 3-1-2-1.

An uneven measure like 7/4 often breaks down as 4/4 + 3/4, but instead of simply concatenating 4/4's 3-1-2-1 with 3/4's 2-1-1 to make 3-1-2-1-2-1-1, a representation of 4-1-2-1-3-1-1 reflects the measure's initial division into 4/4 + 3/4 by making the beginning of the 3/4 measure into a "second-rank" downbeat.

When the quarter-note beat of one of these meters is subdivided into eighth notes, this inclusion can be represented by adding one to each of the numbers and then placing a 1 after each of them. For example, 3/4 (2-1-1) with eighth notes would be 3-1-2-1-2-1. 7/4 (4-1-2-1-3-1-1) would be 5-1-2-1-3-1-2-1-4-1-2-1-2-1.

2. Now, given a certain series of numbers, its cumulation is a series of numbers that sum the original series starting from the left and up to that point. For example, the cumulation of 2-1-1 is 2-(2+1)-(2+1+1) or 2-3-4. The cumulation of 3-1-2-1 is 3-4-6-7.

3. Lastly, a cumulation mod 2 of a series is a series's cumulation where every even number is replaced by 0 and every odd number is replaced by 1. For example, whereas the cumulation of 2-1-1 is 2-3-4, the cumulation mod 2 of this series is 0-1-0. The cumulation mod 2 of 3-1-2-1 is 1-0-0-1.

Below is an 7/4 example from the Overture to Leonard Bernstein's Candide -- placed into time signatures commensurate with the discussion above -- that shows 1) the 7/4 meter as a series of positive integers, 2) the culmination of the series, and 3) the culmination mod 2 of the series.



Below is a video with a score and recording of the second movement of Ligeti's Musica ricercata; attend to the first four measures.

I've re-notated these four measures to make a steady stream of eighth notes, and analyzed the music using the methods outlined above.



Notice how the alternation between 0s and 1s in the culmination mod 2 of the first measure, the second measure, and the third and fourth measures as a single measure of 7/4, corresponds exactly to these measure's alternations between the two pitches that open the movement. Each fermata both resets the metrical hierarchy and toggles the pitch-meter mapping.

Thanks to Nick Shaheed for encouraging me to think about this music.